THE 38 BEST Italian Restaurants in Myrtle Beach, SC - 2024 Restaurantji (2024)

Customers` Favorites

“We're from Connecticut visiting friends. The restaurant that had been recommended by our concierge. It wasn't to our liking but a customer recommended you. Are we glad he did! We didn't have reservations, but the friendly hostess had us seated in a few minute.Our calamari appetizer was some if the best we've had. My wife and friends all enjoyed a terrific linguini with class. I had veal saltimbocca which again some of the best I've enjoyed. The wine was excellent and our server friendly, professional and very knowledgeable about the menu. Great tiramasu finished the meal.I can't tell you how much we enjoyed this experience in an upscale but relaxed restaurant. I only wish we could stay in the area longer so we could come again.Again, thaks and I'll make sure to leave an online review.“

Customers` Favorites

“Beautiful restaurant! Our waiter Nick was very attentive without being over the top. The drinks were delicious, our meals were excellent. I had the carbonara, a favorite, and it did not disappoint. I added 2 scallops & they were cooked to perfection. My husband had the chicken parm & was very pleased with his choice. We would definitely return to this restaurant“

Customers` Favorites

“The best meal we had while in Myrtle Beach. The food was fantastic. The wait staff was very attentive. The only downside was VR would not accept a gift card received from our local timeshare.“

Customers` Favorites

“A update to my earlier review…this wonderful place also has delicious pasta dishes and sandwiches. Just ordered food for delivery again tonight and it was all scrumptious!! They delivered right to our room at our hotel.Previous review:Very prompt delivery and delicious pizza!! We had the meat lover’s pizza and a pepperoni pizza and they were both excellent. This is one of the best pizza places in the area!“

Customers` Favorites

“Some of the best dinning I've had in a long time. The food was amazing! My friend and I got the margherita pizza, penne vodka, and some of their new desserts. Best pizza in Myrtle Beach for sure! All of the servers helped each other out and they were all so friendly and welcoming. I can not wait to visit this resturant again.“

Customers` Favorites

“Crave was recommended to my wife and I by Nick at the Hook & Barrel, and we are very happy that he did! Walking in the door you’re greeted by those fantastic Italian restaurant aromas, and we were seated immediately. Ariel was our server, and I don’t think we could have been treated any better! She patiently went over their specials, and her recommendations were spot on!As she was putting our remaining food in carry out containers, we were just chatting with her and happened to mention that we had an anniversary coming up later in the week. She congratulated us and went to get the check, and when she returned to the table she had two complimentary Lemoncello and Whipped Cream shots as an anniversary gift! Very, very thoughtful, and just put a perfect ending to an already wonderful experience.Highly recommend Crave (and Ariel) to anyone looking for a delicious meal and first rate service.“

Customers` Favorites

“By it's the best Italian restaurant I've ever been to. Our waiter Sebastian gave us an excellent service. He was very attentive with us. He made our experience a moment to remember. The food was the highlight of the evening. We ordered the mussels, sangria, house merlot, pasta and the ravioli. The taste, presentation were outstanding. We will definitely come back if we have the chance.“

Customers` Favorites

“It was Mother's day and the restaurant was busy. Our waitress Sasha was outstanding and even though the restaurant was busy.... she treated us as though we were the only ones there. I tried the Veal Osso Buco for the first time there and although it was good, it wasn't exactly what I expected. My wife had the chicken Sorrento and it was excellent. I would highly recommend this restaurant. We will definitely be back!“

Customers` Favorites

“Best meal on our entire trip to Myrtle Beach. Staff was attentive and super friendly. Food was out of this world. The homemade bread with the peppered oil dip was my favorite thing there. SO GOOD! Great atmosphere, amazing food. If I could give it more than 5 stars, I would.“

Customers` Favorites

“First impressions of this small hometown Italian restaurant is cozy and the atmosphere is wonderful.we were first greeted by the hostess’ and were very quickly seat and asked if we would prefer booth or table which is a big plus for me. Andre our waiter was on point throughout the entirety of this entire let’s call it an experience because the customer courtesy, communication and attention to detail is not only all there but 100% on point. We had the fried calamari which was cooked perfectly as well as fried mozzarella sticks which were very good as well. As for main course I got the linguini with mussels in a white sauce and I paired it with their house Pinot Grigio and the pair worked like a hand in a glove. My wife got the shrimp scampi over linguini and hers was phenomenal as well the portions are very sufficient as we both brought about half of our dinner home with us. Overall the experience at Luigi’s Trattoria was without a doubt a superb choice for anyone looking for an authentic Italian restaurant with possibly the best food in the area.“

Customers` Favorites

“I came to the area for a few days for work as a physician in a nearby hospital and after a rough call day, I wanted to get my favorite type of food which is Italian. I have eaten Italian food in multiple places of the country and this has to be one of the, if not the best Italian restaurant I have ever ate from. I could easily tell that the food was authentic and the atmosphere of the restaurant was unparalleled. Food aside, the owner was very nice and you can just tell his passion for running the restaurant, that alone was enough to impress me. If I am ever back in myrtle beach I will definitely return and will be recommending this place to all my friends and family.“

Customers` Favorites

“Found this joint during a pizza Google search and what a find it was! The cheese pizza had a nice sweet sauce with a thin crust. The cheese blend was outstanding. Huge 18" pie. (The way a pizza should be!). Also grabbed a Caesar salad - wow! Delicious!“

Customers` Favorites

“I love coming to Sole, I've been coming here for the last year every time I visit and its one of the only good Italian spots around. I'm from Jersey/Philly so I'm use to good food and most of Myrtle beaches food is not so good, but Sole is really good and consistent every time I come by and I love it. Its family owned and everyone that's always there is nice. I usually always get the same things, the escargot, bruschetta and the pear fiocchi and their all really good, I would definitely recommend.“

Customers` Favorites

“The sandwiches were so GREAT! Tasty, hearty...kinda like our delis back home on Long Island! And Capicola was nice and spicy. The cannoli were big and DELICIOUS!We were upset about the cookies. Linzer cookies were stale and the jam was gummy and not much of it.The pignoli cookies were a bit pricy for stale cookies.WE would go back time and again, but will skip the cookies.“

Customers` Favorites

“Have a great time and they are constantly making improvements. The owner checks on every table and although it’s outside if it’s on the cooler side the place is heated. The girls are excellent waitresses. I recommend giving Water Way House a visit for a great time! Hope you enjoy!!!“

Customers` Favorites

“First time at Nonno's and couldn't have been more impressed with the quality and price of the food. I ordered Ziti and it exceeded my expectations. Portions are large. The sauce was perfect!! Highly recommend the Cannoli's as well - delicious!!“

Customers` Favorites

“Always awesome! Love the Panzos.“

Customers` Favorites

“LOVE LOVE LOVE! The Fillet with fried shrimp was amazing! If I could do 10 stars they’d get it. Alexis our server was awesome! We got there at 5 and watched her get sat 5 tables, almost at the same time, one of them being a large party. She handed it so well and stayed calm. Amazing server with amazing food! We will definitely be back! Thank you!“

Customers` Favorites

“We absolutely loved it here!!! Between happy hour and live music it was just perfect. Drinks were great, food was delicious and the vibe was amazing. If you’re looking for a place to go to for dinner or just drinks, this is the place!!!! Cannot recommend them enough!!!!! Zach was absolutely wonderful behind the bar!!!! Will be back!!!“

Customers` Favorites

“The best Italian restaurant in Myrtle Beach . Very reasonable prices great food and excellent service by Nikolin . T . We are coming in Myrtle Beach for winter months and eat at this restaurant several times during our stay . We always ask for the same server . He make us feel home . Thank you Nikolin from Canada .“

Customers` Favorites

“My family hosted a birthday party here and our experience exceeded our expectations. Andrew was so accommodating. He gave us great suggestions and made sure that all our needs were met. The food is fabulous! We had many options from appetizers, pasta, chicken, pizza and desserts. Absolutely give them a try!“

Customers` Favorites

“Olive Garden has always been a staple in my family but it has been a little challenging with 2 overstimulated boys with special needs at times. Its one of the only non fast food places my kids eat all their food at. It was both me and their mother's birthday this week (Her's on Monday and mine on Thursday). We had the pleasure of having Mackenzie serve us. I have worked in both hospitality and retail/customer service for the better part of 18 years. Mackenzie was probably the best server I have ever witnessed. You would have thought her and my 10 year old son with sensory processing disorder were best friends. She truly is a remarkable person. Any time you visit this place I recommend requesting her.“

“Excellent personable service. Their food is awesome and found everything I was looking for.Kid-friendliness: My kids weren’t with us but I know they’d love their food. It’s what they grew up on. Ready made meals you can get as much or as little as you want. Especially since kids usually don’t eat a lot.Wheelchair accessibility: No stairs and the front double door is larger enough for a wheelchair to fit through.“

Customers` Favorites

“This is my favorite Italian restaurant. Definitely make a reservation. Our waitress was very pleasant, efficient and professional. I has shrimp parmesean. It was greatThe shrimp are large with lots of melted cheese and it came with salad or soup and pasta. The bread was served warm with a dipping sauce. Very nice warm atmosphere. Truly a wonderful experience.“

Customers` Favorites

“The food was good, the food was pretty cheap. I got a meat lovers pizza, which is five dollars but I wanted hot sauce which they wanted me to pay one extra dollar for so I feel like you shouldn’t charge an extra dollar for hot sauce when I’m already paying five dollars for a slice of pizza but the food was good.“

Customers` Favorites

“Everything was great and a Special thanks to Tammy for helping my wife in the restroom!!!“

Customers` Favorites

“Their meatballs are delicious and the pizza is great, but the cashier didn’t think it was important to thank a customer who spent x amount of money which pays her salary. I don’t recommend the garlic knots unless you want a mouthful of greasy butter.“

Customers` Favorites

“Had the chicken scaripelli! The smallest piece of chicken with with an un noticeable piece of prosciutto, 1 paper thin round slice of eggplant all floating in a brown sauce! The penne was floating in marinara sauce! This used to be my favorite Italian restaurant!“

Customers` Favorites

“Absolutely the best authentic Italian in Myrtle Beach, a quaint atmosphere with dishes you can taste the love in! Came last year and ensured this place was on the itinerary for this year’s trip! 100% recommend the Veal Neptune Platter with béarnaise and the drinks are perfect!“

Customers` Favorites

“I come here several times a week to indulge in their delicious food and their tasty Chardonnay or Pinot. The staff is always so friendly and the soft music playing in the background is always a great addition to a good dinner here. They now have amazing dinner specials and I am taking advantage of those. Don’t hesitate to come give them a try. You won’t regret it! -China“

Customers` Favorites

“If you like Italian food, a great atmosphere, and outstanding food. You have to come to this wonderful gem in Myrtle Beach. The owner DOM came out and sat with us for a few minutes. We got a little history and you could tell he takes pride in how he manages his restaurant, takes care of his staff to include their customers are all treated like family.Their opening salad was a good touch not too big but did what a salad is suppose to do. we had calamari for an appetizer and Boy. that was the way to start the meal.when ended with a great lemon cake, and a kind sendoff from staff. If you’re in Myrtle Beach, you have to come to this place before you go home.“

Customers` Favorites

“Absolutely recommend Grandma’s pizza. From the fresh chunky San Marzano tomatoes, to the basil and the garlic it is an absolute must try. Our entire family and team loves this and the owners are fabulous and the team. Do yourself a favor and treat yourself and your family to Gino’s real New York Pizza.“

Customers` Favorites

“We ordered 2 large , thin crust pizzas, for delivery on Friday night for our neighbor's get together . Both pizzas were cooked to perfection and good , plus the delivery service was outstanding . No complaints . Our group has ordered before and we will continue to order from Gino's“

Customers` Favorites

“I was in town for work last week and craving pizza. The three places I tried to go first (due to location) were closed. So glad that I ended up at Mama Mia's. I sat at the bar and had terrific service from Svetlana! Her passion and kindness is apparent from the second you met her. I thoroughly enjoyed chatting with her and the food was outstanding! 10/10 recommend and I can't wait to come back and visit next time I'm in the area. Thank you Svetlana and Mama Mia's!“

Customers` Favorites

“The atmosphere was very welcoming and our server was friendly and professional. The food was delicious. They start out with some garlic rolls which were warm and yummy. We had chicken parmesan, veal parmesan and a salmon dish. Great portions of everything. There was music playing in the background which was nice.“

Customers` Favorites

“Quick delivery food was hot and delicious! The Wednesday Greek special is terrific!! Yummy gyro soft bread delicious meat and a definite two hander! White pizza great crust just enough garlic and cheese. Will definitely order from here again“

Customers` Favorites

“Angelo's has always been a great experience and last night wasn't very different. Rhetha provided great service to our party of 8 (with a baby).The ONLY negative thing I can offer is that, for some reason, the garlic mashed potatoes were extremely Salty. So much so that I asked for a docent side as soon as I had the first bite. The green beans that replaced them were very good, so it worked out just fine! The steak which I requested med rare was cooked just right! WIN!Angelo's has been such a long standing staple in the Myrtle Beach area and I have enjoyed every visit over the last MANY years...If you've not been, it's wish a visit, at least in my opinion!“

Customers` Favorites

“It was late Wednesday and my brother had just gotten into town and was hungry. We decided to give Marcos a try, since we had never been there. It was great. We had a deluxe pizza, wings, and a pizzioli? I think that's what it's called with chicken cheese and ranch on the side.I wanted to say thank you to Skylar for the excellent customer service. I accidentally placed my order twice online lol. He called me personally and wanted to make sure I did not want two orders (the same order). I felt that was nice of him to do and he was very professional. We will be ordering again in the future. Thank you Marcos.“